Rethinking Uncertainly Missing and Ambiguous Visual Modality in Multi-Modal Entity Alignment

30 Jul 2023  ยท  Zhuo Chen, Lingbing Guo, Yin Fang, Yichi Zhang, Jiaoyan Chen, Jeff Z. Pan, Yangning Li, Huajun Chen, Wen Zhang ยท

As a crucial extension of entity alignment (EA), multi-modal entity alignment (MMEA) aims to identify identical entities across disparate knowledge graphs (KGs) by exploiting associated visual information. However, existing MMEA approaches primarily concentrate on the fusion paradigm of multi-modal entity features, while neglecting the challenges presented by the pervasive phenomenon of missing and intrinsic ambiguity of visual images. In this paper, we present a further analysis of visual modality incompleteness, benchmarking latest MMEA models on our proposed dataset MMEA-UMVM, where the types of alignment KGs covering bilingual and monolingual, with standard (non-iterative) and iterative training paradigms to evaluate the model performance. Our research indicates that, in the face of modality incompleteness, models succumb to overfitting the modality noise, and exhibit performance oscillations or declines at high rates of missing modality. This proves that the inclusion of additional multi-modal data can sometimes adversely affect EA. To address these challenges, we introduce UMAEA , a robust multi-modal entity alignment approach designed to tackle uncertainly missing and ambiguous visual modalities. It consistently achieves SOTA performance across all 97 benchmark splits, significantly surpassing existing baselines with limited parameters and time consumption, while effectively alleviating the identified limitations of other models. Our code and benchmark data are available at https://github.com/zjukg/UMAEA.

PDF Abstract

Datasets


Introduced in the Paper:

UMVM

Used in the Paper:

DBP15K MMKG OpenEA Benchmark

Results from the Paper


 Ranked #1 on Multi-modal Entity Alignment on UMVM-oea-d-w-v2 (using extra training data)

     Get a GitHub badge
Task Dataset Model Metric Name Metric Value Global Rank Uses Extra
Training Data
Result Benchmark
Entity Alignment dbp15k fr-en UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.818 # 12
Entity Alignment dbp15k fr-en UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.873 # 9
Entity Alignment dbp15k ja-en UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.857 # 9
Entity Alignment dbp15k ja-en UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.801 # 11
Entity Alignment DBP15k zh-en UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.800 # 14
Entity Alignment DBP15k zh-en UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.856 # 9
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-dbp-fr-en UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.818 # 3
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-dbp-fr-en UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.873 # 1
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-dbp-ja-en UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.857 # 1
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-dbp-ja-en UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.801 # 4
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-dbp-zh-en UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.856 # 1
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-dbp-zh-en UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.800 # 4
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-oea-d-w-v1 UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.904 # 4
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-oea-d-w-v1 UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.945 # 1
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-oea-d-w-v2 UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.948 # 3
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-oea-d-w-v2 UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.973 # 1
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-oea-en-de UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.956 # 3
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-oea-en-de UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.974 # 1
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-oea-en-fr UMAEA (w/o surf) Hits@1 0.895 # 1
Multi-modal Entity Alignment UMVM-oea-en-fr UMAEA (w/o surf & iter ) Hits@1 0.848 # 4

Methods


No methods listed for this paper. Add relevant methods here