Do we really need temporal convolutions in action segmentation?

26 May 2022  ·  Dazhao Du, Bing Su, Yu Li, Zhongang Qi, Lingyu Si, Ying Shan ·

Action classification has made great progress, but segmenting and recognizing actions from long untrimmed videos remains a challenging problem. Most state-of-the-art methods focus on designing temporal convolution-based models, but the inflexibility of temporal convolutions and the difficulties in modeling long-term temporal dependencies restrict the potential of these models. Transformer-based models with adaptable and sequence modeling capabilities have recently been used in various tasks. However, the lack of inductive bias and the inefficiency of handling long video sequences limit the application of Transformer in action segmentation. In this paper, we design a pure Transformer-based model without temporal convolutions by incorporating temporal sampling, called Temporal U-Transformer (TUT). The U-Transformer architecture reduces complexity while introducing an inductive bias that adjacent frames are more likely to belong to the same class, but the introduction of coarse resolutions results in the misclassification of boundaries. We observe that the similarity distribution between a boundary frame and its neighboring frames depends on whether the boundary frame is the start or end of an action segment. Therefore, we further propose a boundary-aware loss based on the distribution of similarity scores between frames from attention modules to enhance the ability to recognize boundaries. Extensive experiments show the effectiveness of our model.

PDF Abstract

Results from the Paper


Task Dataset Model Metric Name Metric Value Global Rank Result Benchmark
Action Segmentation 50Salads EUT F1@10% 89.2 # 1
F1@25% 87.5 # 1
F1@50% 81 # 1
Edit 82.9 # 1
Acc 87.4 # 1
Action Segmentation 50 Salads EUT F1@10% 89.2 # 5
Edit 82.9 # 8
Acc 87.4 # 7
F1@25% 87.5 # 8
F1@50% 81 # 8
Action Segmentation Breakfast EUT F1@10% 76.2 # 10
F1@50% 59.8 # 8
Acc 75 # 7
Edit 74.6 # 13
F1@25% 71.8 # 8
Action Segmentation GTEA EUT F1@10% 88.2 # 20
F1@50% 74 # 21
Acc 77 # 21
Edit 83.9 # 18
F1@25% 87.2 # 16

Methods